| 1836–1837 |
Joseph Story | Smith Thompson | John McLean | Henry Baldwin | James M. Wayne | Philip P. Barbour
|
| 1837–1838 |
Joseph Story | Smith Thompson | John McLean | Henry Baldwin | James M. Wayne | Philip P. Barbour | John Catron
|
| 1838–1841 |
Joseph Story | Smith Thompson | John McLean | Henry Baldwin | James M. Wayne | Philip P. Barbour | John Catron | John McKinley
|
| 1842–1843 |
Joseph Story | Smith Thompson | John McLean | Henry Baldwin | James M. Wayne | John Catron | John McKinley | Peter V. Daniel
|
| 1843–1844 |
Joseph Story | John McLean | Henry Baldwin | James M. Wayne | John Catron | John McKinley | Peter V. Daniel
|
| 1845–1846 |
John McLean | James M. Wayne | John Catron | John McKinley | Peter V. Daniel | Samuel Nelson | Levi Woodbury
|
| 1846–1851 |
John McLean | James M. Wayne | John Catron | John McKinley | Peter V. Daniel | Samuel Nelson | Levi Woodbury | Robert C. Grier
|
| 1851–1852 |
John McLean | James M. Wayne | John Catron | John McKinley | Peter V. Daniel | Samuel Nelson | Robert C. Grier | Benjamin R. Curtis
|
| 1853–1857 |
John McLean | James M. Wayne | John Catron | Peter V. Daniel | Samuel Nelson | Robert C. Grier | Benjamin R. Curtis | John A. Campbell
|
| 1858–1860 |
John McLean | James M. Wayne | John Catron | Peter V. Daniel | Samuel Nelson | Robert C. Grier | John A. Campbell | Nathan Clifford
|
| 1860–1861 |
John McLean | James M. Wayne | John Catron | Samuel Nelson | Robert C. Grier | John A. Campbell | Nathan Clifford
|
| 1862–1863 |
James M. Wayne | John Catron | Samuel Nelson | Robert C. Grier | Nathan Clifford | Noah H. Swayne | Samuel F. Miller | David Davis
|
| 1863–1864 |
James M. Wayne | John Catron | Samuel Nelson | Robert C. Grier | Nathan Clifford | Noah H. Swayne | Samuel F. Miller | David Davis | Stephen Johnson Field
|